| Basis |
West |
India |
| Secular Traditions |
Evolved secularism without deep historical roots. |
Deeply rooted since the Indus Valley Civilization. |
| State-Religion Separation |
Rigid separation with minimal state influence on religion. |
“Principled distance” maintains neutrality. |
| Status of Religions |
Focus on individual rights; less emphasis on communal aspects. |
Equal status for all religions. |
| Freedom |
Emphasis on individual freedom of religion. |
Equal protection, respect, and treatment to all religions, balancing personal and community rights. |
| State Aid to Religious Institutions |
No state aid |
State aid to religious institutions (Article 30). |
| Public Display of Religious Symbols: |
Opposition to public display of religious symbols for maintaining a secular public sphere. |
Freedom to practice religion with symbols (e.g., Sikh kirpans) and recognition of religious symbols in public life. |
| Intra and Inter-Community Domination |
Addresses intra-community domination. |
Mitigates both intra and inter-community domination, encouraging balanced representation. |
| Religious Reform |
Internal reforms within religious communities. |
Secular traditions with a history of religious diversity and coexistence. |
| Plurality of Religions |
Emphasizes religious diversity. |
Acceptance of the plurality of religions, promoting coexistence and mutual respect. |
| Government Interaction with Religious Groups |
Limited |
interacts regularly |